In BDP Construction Limited v Cygnet Behavioural Health Limited, the Technology and Construction Court was asked to enforce an adjudicator’s decision arising from a dispute over which contractual documents governed the parties’ relationship and whether liquidated damages were recoverable. The judgment provides useful guidance on the scope of an adjudicator’s jurisdiction, the requirements of natural justice and the risks that can arise where contractual documentation is not clearly agreed or executed. This article provides a summary of the judgment and highlights its key implications for the construction industry.
Background
The parties were BDP Construction Limited (“BDP”) and Cygnet Behavioural Health Limited (“Cygnet”). The contract in question was a JCT Design and Build Contract 2016 with a schedule of amendments (the “Contract”). The Contract was for the design and construction of a hospital at 140 Wolverhampton Road, Wolverhampton (“the Works”), for which BDP was the contractor and Cygnet was the employer. Practical completion was achieved on 18 July 2024.
The dispute concerned Cygnet’s retention of sums allegedly due in respect of liquidated damages and defects. As the Contract had not been executed by the parties, a key issue was which contractual documents and terms formed part of the parties’ agreement on the same.
The Adjudication
BDP commenced an adjudication on the basis that the Contract comprised:
- A JCT Design and Build Contract 2016;
- The amendments allegedly provided by Cygnet on or around 13 March 2024 (the “BDP Amendments”); and
- Appendices 1-8 of the Contract Particulars.
Under the BDP Amendments, the completion date was 26 April 2024, and liquidated damages were payable at £14,500 per week.
Cygnet disputed BDP’s position, asserting that the relevant contract documentation was based on a version dated 27 September 2022 instead. Under that version, the completion date was 29 February 2024, and liquidated damages were payable at £1,000 per day. In any event, Cygnet did not accept that BDP Amendments formed part of the parties’ agreement.
Amongst other things, the Adjudicator was required to determine:
- the contractual completion date; and
- the applicable liquidated damages provisions.
The Adjudicator commented that the parties’ positions on the contractual documentation were “totally polarised”.
The Adjudicator found that the contractual completion date was 29 February 2024 but concluded that neither party had established that its proposed liquidated damages provision formed part of the Contract. Consequently, Cygnet was not entitled to recover liquidated damages. The Adjudicator also rejected BDP’s claim for an extension of time or any extension of time for that matter.
The significance of this finding became central to the subsequent enforcement proceedings, where the Court considered whether the Adjudicator was entitled to reject both parties’ competing positions on liquidated damages rather than selecting one of the options presented.
Court Proceedings
BDP sought to enforce the Adjudicator’s Decision by way of summary judgment.
Cygnet contended that the Adjudicator’s treatment of the liquidated damages issue amounted to a breach of natural justice and/or an excess of his jurisdiction. The arguments can be summarised as follows:
Jurisdiction
The Court rejected Cygnet’s jurisdiction challenge, holding that the Adjudicator was not confined to selecting one of the parties’ competing liquidated damages rates. In the absence of any agreement restricting the Adjudicator’s remit, it was open to him to conclude that neither party had proved its asserted contractual position.
Natural Justice
The Court held that there was no breach of natural justice because the Adjudicator was not relying on a new issue or new evidence. Rather, the Adjudicator was assessing evidence that had already been submitted in the Adjudication and concluding that neither party had discharged its burden of proof in relation to the rate of liquidated damages which were to apply. Notably, the Court observed that the Adjudicator had jurisdiction to “resolve the dispute in the manner he did”.
Accordingly, the Court enforced the Adjudicator’s Decision in full, awarding BDP for the sum of £136,769 plus Adjudicator’s costs, plus interest.
Implications for the Construction Industry
Firstly, this judgment confirms that an adjudicator is entitled to reject both parties’ positions where neither has sufficiently established its case. This serves as a reminder that parties should ensure their evidential case is fully substantiated rather than assuming that an adjudicator must choose between the alternatives presented.
Secondly, it demonstrates the evidential importance of maintaining clear contractual records of negotiations, revisions and document transmissions. In BDP v Cygnet, the parties’ inability to establish which set of amendments had been exchanged and agreed upon ultimately proved critical to the outcome of the liquidated damages dispute.
Thirdly, whilst construction projects often proceed before formal execution of the contract, this judgment demonstrates the risks associated with that approach and why a contract should first be executed. Where a contract is left unexecuted, uncertainty may arise as to which terms have been agreed, potentially leading to costly disputes concerning matters such as completion dates, extension of time and liquidated damages.