On the face of it, if it is financially viable to do so, passing on wealth at an early stage makes perfect sense. However, if the intention is to keep funds “in the family”, the position may not be straightforward.
What happens on divorce?
Scots law requires divorcing spouses to share fairly any wealth which either (or both) of them have accrued during the period of their marriage with the exception of anything acquired by gift from a third party (i.e. a person who is not one of the spouses) or succession. One might therefore be forgiven for thinking that assets acquired from older generations of the family ought to be perfectly safe from any claim made by the beneficiary’s spouse, if the marriage ends. The reality is that people rarely acquire assets and leave them in the state in which they are received. A gift or bequest of money, for example, may be spent on a new house, car or another “special something” the recipient has always coveted. An asset they have been gifted or have inherited may be sold and the sale proceeds used to purchase a newer model. Whilst it is likely to make the family happy to see the gift being enjoyed, problems can arise if the beneficiary finds themselves in a position where their then relationship later ends. By changing the form of the asset they were gifted, they have put it firmly “in the pot” for division upon divorce.
In such circumstances, legal arguments may be advanced to suggest that the source of funds used to acquire the “new” asset ought to be taken into account when working out how that asset should be divided. That may result in the asset being shared unequally between the spouses, with the intended beneficiary acquiring the larger proportion. That outcome does, however, rely on either the goodwill of the spouse or a court exercising its discretion..
Business interests
Businesses interests can also cause difficulties. Bringing a child into the family business as a partner or shareholder is of course an exciting development. As long as the business remains in exactly the same form throughout the child’s marriage, the business interest will not form part of the matrimonial property for division (although other arguments may be made which go beyond the scope of this insight). The difficulties arise, however, when (often for tax reasons) a change is later made to the nature of the business. For example, a decision may be made to transition from a partnership to a limited company. If that change occurs, the shareholding becomes matrimonial property and will require to be taken into account on separation. This is unlikely to be what was intended, particularly as the business may have been trading for many years (or even generations) before the divorcing couple even met.
Pensions
It is a fact of life that people change their employment from time to time. A consequence of that is that individuals can often be members of numerous different pension schemes. In some instances, their membership of the pension may have commenced prior to the marriage, but contributions may have subsequently been made during the marriage. In other instances, contributions to the pension will have commenced and ended during the marriage. At the other extreme, the pension may have commenced prior to the marriage, and no contributions may have been made during the marriage. It can be tempting to consolidate all of the rights which have accrued under the different schemes into one scheme. The difficulty with this approach is that in doing so it makes it very difficult to work out which parts of the pension fall squarely within the pot to be divided upon divorce and which parts it could be argued should be excluded.
What about those who are cohabiting?
The position is different for cohabiting couples who are living together without being married. There is no matrimonial property to be divided. Instead, a claim can be made if either of the parties can demonstrate that they have been financially disadvantaged in the interests of the relationship or in the interests of any child of the relationship. Alternatively, they will require to demonstrate that the person with whom they have been cohabiting has been advantaged by their contributions. Each cohabitant’s position will be considered at the beginning and end of the relationship. Clearly any gifts or inheritances can substantially change the financial landscape. Here, the biggest risk is a cohabitant making a spurious claim at the end of the relationship to elicit the payment of a capital sum from their former partner. The temptation may be to give in to their demands to some degree to avoid protracted litigation and the associated costs. The Scottish Law commission recently considered whether greater opportunities to make a claim should be afforded to cohabiting couples at the end of their relationship. Legislative reform is set to follow [SL1] and the financial risks are therefore only set to increase. The right to make a claim against a cohabitant also exists where the relationship ends by the death of one of the cohabitants, on the condition that the couple were still in a cohabiting relationship at the time of the death and provided that the deceased died intestate.
Options to regulate matters
There is, however, a way to avoid all of this uncertainty and that is by the couple entering into an agreement. This can take various forms depending on the circumstances of the couple involved. A prenuptial agreement can be used to ring fence assets which are not to be included for division on divorce. It can also stipulate that anything bought using funds derived from those assets will not be included. Likewise, the agreement can make it clear that gifted or inherited funds or assets will not be included , nor will anything acquired with funds derived from anything which is gifted or inherited. That provides financial freedom to those in receipt of wealth from third parties. If it is too late and the intended beneficiary is already married, a post-nuptial agreement can be prepared. That can deal with a very specific scenario (e.g. an interest in a company which is being transferred) or a more general situation such as agreeing that anything bought with gifted or inherited funds will be excluded for division on divorce. Similar agreements can be put in place prior to or during a cohabiting relationship to set out clearly what the position will be if the relationship ends.
Securing legal advice in relation to these issues at an early opportunity is crucial. Please get in touch with one of our family lawyers if you require assistance.
Contributor
Legal Director