On 30 October 2026, the Supreme Court granted permission to appeal to the appellant, Aubrey Weis, in the case of Weis v Greater Manchester Combined Authority [2025] CAT 41 and [2026] EWCA Civ 825, which was the second challenge brought under the Subsidy Control Act 2022 (the “2022 Act”). Mr Weis’ challenge was dismissed at first instance by the Competition Appeal Tribunal (“CAT”) and subsequently dismissed again on appeal by the Court of Appeal.

Background

We have previously blogged about the first instance decision by the CAT, and the decision of the Court of Appeal. In summary, in November 2024, the Greater Manchester Combined Authority (‘GMCA’) entered into two loan agreements with the Renaker property development group (“Renaker”) to finance the construction of two high-rise residential blocks in Manchester. The loans were made from the Greater Manchester Housing Investment Loan Fund which has the primary objective of creating new homes in the Greater Manchester area.

Aubrey Weis is the owner of a competing property developer in Manchester, Weis Group. He challenged GMCA’s decision to approve the loans in the CAT in June 2024, before the loan agreements were entered into, arguing that they constituted unlawful subsidies under the 2022 Act.

Framework under the 2022 Act

The 2022 Act provides that a subsidy is any financial assistance which:

  1. is given by a public body or otherwise out of public funds;
  2. confers an advantage on an enterprise (i.e. a person who conducts activities on a market);
  3. is specific to that enterprise (i.e. not available to everyone on the same terms); and
  4. is liable to have an effect on international trade or competition within the UK.

Financial assistance must meet all of the above conditions to constitute a subsidy under the 2022 Act.

In order to confer an advantage on an enterprise, financial assistance must be given on terms which are more favourable than the enterprise could reasonably expect to obtain on the market. This is known as the “Commercial Market Operator” or “CMO” principle. This was the basis on which GMCA considered the loans to Renaker did not constitute subsidies within the meaning of the 2022 Act.

The Competition Appeal Tribunal proceedings

Mr Weis argued that the loans were not given on terms that a commercial lender would have offered. He therefore considered that the CMO principle did not apply and the loans ought to have been treated as subsidies under the 2022 Act. As GMCA had not treated them as such, they had not complied with any of the duties incumbent on them under the 2022 Act when awarding a subsidy, and accordingly the loans were unlawful.

In July 2025, the Competition Appeal Tribunal found in favour of GMCA, concluding that each of the loans had been awarded on a CMO basis, and that GMCA had not acted unreasonably in concluding that it was acting on a CMO basis. The loans therefore did not confer an advantage on Renaker and could not constitute subsidies, nor by extension unlawful subsidies, under the 2022 Act.

Mr Weis subsequently appealed to the Court of Appeal. However, the Court of Appeal upheld the CAT’s decision, finding that the CAT had not erred in law and had been entitled to reach the view that it did, and the appeal was dismissed on 29 June 2026. Mr Weis subsequently applied to the Supreme Court for permission to appeal.

Application for permission to appeal to the Supreme Court

Mr Weis’ sought permission to appeal on three grounds. However, the court granted permission to hear the appeal on grounds 1 and 2 only:

  • Ground 1: what is the CAT’s jurisdiction in respect of applications for review under the 2022 Act where the main issue is whether the financial assistance given is a subsidy?
  • Ground 2: when determining whether there is a subsidy, should the CAT determine compliance with the CMO principle under s.3(2) of the 2022 Act for itself, or review the decision of the public authority on general public law grounds?

Mr Weis’ third ground of appeal was whether the CAT’s jurisdiction is limited to a consideration of compliance with the CMO principle under s. 3(2), or whether it extends to considering free-standing grounds of public law review. However, the Supreme Court held that the third ground did not raise an arguable point of law of public importance, and permission to appeal this aspect was therefore refused.

Key takeaways

The Supreme Court’s decision on the grounds of appeal to which it has granted permission will bring welcome clarity on the role of the CAT, and the approach that it is required to adopt, in considering challenges under the 2022 Act.

In particular, our previous blog on the Court of Appeal’s decision noted that the Court of Appeal had found the question of whether something constitutes a subsidy to be a question that the CAT itself must consider and answer based on an objective analysis of the position at the time that the subsidy decision was taken, meaning that a decision to award financial assistance on a CMO basis can be defended by a public authority retrospectively using evidence that it did not have in front of it when it originally gave the subsidy (marking a departure from EU State aid law). The grounds of appeal which have been accepted afford the Supreme Court the opportunity to uphold or overturn that finding, either preserving or restricting the flexibility awarded to public authorities in that respect.

If Mr Weis succeeds, this could cement the importance of a public authority properly considering subsidy control rules whenever it provides financial assistance, restrict an authority’s ability to justify a “no subsidy” decision after the fact, and place greater emphasis on authorities having robust evidence and reasons at the time of their funding decisions to support reliance on the CMO principle.

The Court of Appeal has also recently granted permission to appeal in the case of Bristol Airport v Welsh Ministers [2026] CAT 30, which we have also previously written about, which will bring further guidance from the senior courts on the application of the 2022 Act regime. 

If you would like to discuss how this may affect your organisation, please contact Jamie Dunne, Charles Livingstone, or your usual Brodies contact.

Contributors

Jamie Dunne

Legal Director

Emily Tarbet

Associate

Farah Khan

Trainee Solicitor