A subscription can be cancelled in seconds. A box of fresh food cannot be unmade quite so easily. The UK's forthcoming subscription rules promise clearer information, timely reminders and easier exits—but who bears the cost when a customer changes their mind after the ingredients have been bought? This blog unpacks the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 (“DMCCA”), explains how the draft Consumer Subscription Contracts (Cancellation and Information) Regulations 2026 (the “Regulations”) would put its subscription protections into practice, and considers whether the balance tips too far against fresh-food producers and just-in-time suppliers.
Picture Friday's meal box: ingredients bought, vegetables portioned, everything chilled and waiting for the courier. Then the customer cancels. If they exercise a valid cooling-off right before the goods have been legally supplied, the business may have to refund that box despite having incurred much of its cost. Unfortunately, the fish cannot be unfilleted.
Commencement and scope of the new regime
The Government has announced that the new subscription rules are due to come into force on 1 January 2027, subject to parliamentary approval of the implementing Regulations. Targeted at so-called ‘subscription traps’, the reforms are intended to strengthen consumer protection by tackling unwanted subscriptions and removing unnecessary barriers to cancellation. With UK consumers estimated to spend around £1.6 billion each year on unwanted subscriptions, the new regime will place additional obligations on businesses, with greater emphasis on transparency at sign-up, timely reminders and straightforward routes to cancellation.
Broadly, the new regime will apply prospectively to subscription contracts entered into on or after 1 January 2027, meaning that an existing contract will not fall within scope merely because it automatically renews after that date. The regime covers qualifying business-to-consumer subscriptions, including arrangements that automatically renew or continue, and free or discounted offers that convert to paid or higher-priced subscriptions. Businesses should also be mindful of the regime’s territorial reach. Overseas traders are not necessarily outside scope: the rules may apply where a subscription contract has a sufficiently close connection with the UK, even where foreign law has been chosen to govern the agreement.
It does not cover business-to-business contracts, and statutory exclusions must be checked. Food businesses should note the specific exclusion for qualifying micro-grocery arrangements: being a small producer, or selling something fresh, does not by itself establish an exemption.
New Requirements
The DMCCA and the draft Regulations should be read together as complementary parts of the same subscription regime, with the latter providing the detailed requirements necessary to implement and give practical effect to the subscription regime established under the DMCCA. Part 4, Chapter 2 of the DMCCA establishes the subscription framework: information duties, reminders, straightforward exit arrangements and cooling-off rights. The draft Regulations supply the working detail, including notice requirements, extensions of cooling-off periods, and the financial consequences of cancellation. Importantly, the DMCCA's subscription provisions have been enacted but are not yet in force, while the Regulations remain in draft. These forthcoming rules should not be confused with the DMCCA's consumer protections already operating.
Together, they create a regime that reaches across the subscription lifecycle, meaning compliance will require businesses to consider not only their contractual terms, but the customer-facing systems and processes through which subscriptions are entered into, renewed and brought to an end.
Businesses should check the final legislation and commencement arrangements before relying on that timetable. In the meantime, preparation should focus on four practical steps:
- Explain the deal upfront. The DMCCA requires prominent key information before sign-up, alongside fuller pre-contract information. Online customers must be clearly told they are committing to pay. Burying the subscription's essentials in the terms will not be acceptable.
- Send reminders that customers can act on. The DMCCA requires reminders before specified renewal payments, including qualifying trial conversions and longer renewals. The draft Regulations refine those duties: where an introductory offer stays at one discounted rate across several payments, the relevant reminder is tied to the first higher-priced renewal payment. Notices must also be in writing on a durable medium—something the customer can retain, such as an email—and clearly signal the approaching payment and opportunity to end the contract.
- Allow time to reconsider. The DMCCA provides initial cooling-off rights and a new 14-day renewal cooling-off period after qualifying free or discounted periods and certain renewals involving commitments of 12 months or more. The Regulations address extensions where required information or notices are missing, and what must be refunded. The initial right allows consumers to reconsider signing up; the renewal right gives them another opportunity after particular renewals. Neither amounts to a rolling right to cancel every individual delivery, and cancellation does not necessarily mean keeping everything received for free.
- Make leaving straightforward. The DMCCA also sets requirements for exit arrangements and end-of-contract notices. Online sign-up must come with an online route out, without unnecessary obstacles. Stopping future renewal is, however, different from exercising a cooling-off right: easier cancellation does not create an unrestricted right to walk away from every minimum term. There is also a separate remedy where the trader breaks certain subscription duties. Sections 262 and 263 of the DMCCA make compliance with specified duties contractual obligations and give consumers a cancellation right for certain breaches; Part 3 of the draft Regulations works through the resulting refunds and treatment of goods. That is different from simply changing one's mind during a cooling-off period. The distinction matters: a missed reminder can create exposure beyond an otherwise well-run cancellation process.
The consequences of non-compliance with the new requirements extend beyond individual cancellation and refund claims. The subscription requirements sit within the DMCCA’s wider consumer protection regime, supported by the CMA’s direct enforcement powers, including the ability to impose significant financial penalties which may reach up to 10% of a business’s global annual turnover. The new regime therefore represents a material increase in regulatory exposure for businesses offering subscription contracts, making early preparation essential.
The fresh-food catch
A short shelf life matters; making something to order is not enough on its own. The draft Regulations distinguish between perishable goods—those liable to deteriorate or expire rapidly—and bespoke goods, made to a customer's specifications or clearly personalised. Fresh ingredients may qualify as perishable, but a standard meal kit does not become bespoke simply because it is packed after the order arrives. Those definitions shape the cancellation rules that follow.
Why is this a significant change? Under regulation 28 of the existing Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013, the ordinary cooling-off rules exclude goods liable to deteriorate or expire rapidly, as well as bespoke goods. For subscriptions caught by the new regime, suppliers cannot assume that familiar exclusion carries across unchanged. The proposed approach preserves a right to reconsider the subscription while giving more limited protections for perishable goods. That shifts the commercial question from “is this fresh?” to “when was it supplied, and what cancellation right is being exercised?”
Fresh does not mean exempt
Suppliers do get some certainty about the initial cancellation window. Where the goods supplied for sale under the subscription are exclusively perishable or bespoke, that right is limited to the 14 days beginning the day after the contract is entered into. This protection, in regulation 8 of the draft Regulations, depends on giving the required initial cooling-off information, including explaining the restriction. It limits the window; it does not remove cooling-off protection altogether.
Crucially, there is no fresh 14-day cooling-off right with every weekly box. The customer must be within an applicable initial or qualifying renewal cooling-off period, including any extension. Rights concerning faulty goods or a supplier's breach are separate.
Cancellation: who keeps what?
When a customer validly cancels during a cooling-off period, the starting point is that liability for relevant payments falls away and those already made must be refunded. That is the general rule in regulation 11 of the draft Regulations—not a promise to return every payment made over the subscription's lifetime. The applicable period and permitted deductions still matter.
Packed is not necessarily supplied
For fresh-food suppliers, the important exception concerns goods already supplied. Regulation 15 of the draft Regulations allows payment to be retained for qualifying perishable or bespoke goods, together with the permitted standard delivery amount, subject to the relevant information or renewal-notice requirements. It is not a general right to deduct whatever the business has spent preparing an order. Read alongside the general refund rule in regulation 11, it leaves an awkward gap: the supplier may have committed the ingredients, labour and packaging without yet having supplied the goods. A valid cooling-off cancellation in that interval may require a refund even though those costs cannot be recovered.
Two different points of no return
For a just-in-time producer, the commercial point of no return may arrive before the legal one. By Thursday afternoon, Friday's box may have absorbed ingredients, labour, packaging and delivery commitments. The customer's cancellation right may still be running. This is not a problem unique to food, but short shelf lives and limited resale opportunities make it particularly acute for fresh-to-order suppliers.
So can a customer cancel right up to delivery? Potentially, yes—but only while an applicable cancellation right remains available. In evidence submitted to Parliament, Mindful Chef and HelloFresh have raised precisely this concern, treating “supplied” as physical delivery to the customer. On that reading, dispatch would not itself secure the supplier's entitlement to payment for the box. That is the commercial risk the draft creates, not a blanket promise that every customer can cancel every box at the doorstep. Businesses should check the final wording and guidance against their actual fulfilment arrangements; labelling an internal order cut-off the “supply date” cannot resolve the issue.
Fairer for consumers, but at what cost?
The consumer rationale is persuasive: a right to reconsider should not disappear at an invisible warehouse deadline, especially after an introductory offer turns into a more expensive commitment. Yet the supplier's objection is not simply resistance to easier cancellation. A refund cannot reverse food preparation or restore a short shelf life. Although the limited initial window and protection for goods already supplied offer some reassurance, neither creates a general entitlement to recover expenditure on an unsupplied order.
For just-in-time businesses, that mismatch is particularly uncomfortable. Matching purchases closely to confirmed orders can limit surplus stock; late cancellations can undermine that very efficiency. Ingredients may already have been portioned or combined, and chilled goods may be difficult to redirect safely before their useful life runs out. The contracting subscription business bears the consumer-facing refund obligation, but growers and other upstream suppliers could feel the pressure through revised ordering patterns or supply terms. The risk is wider than a lost sale: it is unrecoverable production cost, uncertain demand and avoidable waste.
Consumers may ultimately share some of that cost through higher prices, less generous introductory offers or a narrower range of genuinely fresh products. Those are potential commercial responses, not inevitable outcomes, and their scale will depend on cancellation rates and the business model. Nevertheless, they expose the policy tension: protection against unwanted subscriptions could make the subscriptions people do want more expensive. A clearly disclosed, proportionate pre-delivery cut-off merits consideration as a legislative safeguard—not as something suppliers can simply write into their terms today. The difficult question is where to draw that line without allowing an unnecessarily early production deadline to hollow out the consumer's right.
Reducing the risk: what should suppliers consider?
There is no contractual shortcut, but legal, finance and fulfilment teams can work together to reduce unnecessary exposure:
- Map the exposure. Check which subscriptions and products are caught. Compare cooling-off periods, including trial conversions, with purchasing, packing and supply milestones. Model the cost of cancellations at each stage.
- Get information and notices right. Review sign-up wording, reminders and cooling-off notices, and retain evidence of delivery. The protections discussed above depend on compliance, and the DMCCA puts the burden on the trader to prove that the required information and notices were properly given. Good records could make the difference when a payment is disputed.
- Connect cancellation to fulfilment. Requests should reach billing and production quickly enough to stop avoidable work. Train teams to distinguish stopping renewal from statutory cancellation, and apply the correct refund rules.
- Keep options open where possible. Consider later allocation of ingredients, flexible packing and courier arrangements, and safe redistribution. Review introductory offers against their cancellation exposure, rather than looking only at the sales they generate.
- Do not overpromise what terms can achieve. Clear order cut-offs help planning, but cannot override statutory rights: conflicting terms are ineffective under the DMCCA. A cancellation charge cannot simply be used to restore payment the legislation requires the business to refund.
The bottom line
Making subscriptions easier to understand and leave is a welcome objective. But the DMCCA's rights and the Regulations' refund mechanics must work together in the real world, where fresh-food production cannot be stopped as easily as a recurring payment. Suppliers should prepare their customer journeys and fulfilment systems now, while testing what the final rules mean for the point at which orders become irreversible.
Operational changes can reduce avoidable loss; they cannot eliminate the gap between an irreversible order and a customer's continuing right to cancel. If that gap remains, the commercial consequence may be more waste and higher prices—not just easier exits. Consumers should not be trapped in subscriptions. But a fair regime must also recognise when the kitchen has already passed the point of no return.
With less than two months until implementation, businesses should now be reviewing their existing subscription models, including the end-to-end consumer journey, pre-contract information, renewal notifications, exit mechanisms and refund procedures. While further CMA guidance is anticipated ahead of commencement, businesses should not delay assessing their existing arrangements and implementing any necessary changes, particularly in light of the potential consequences of non-compliance.
Contributors
Partner
Trainee Solicitor