Providing care for an elderly or vulnerable family member is often regarded as a natural part of family life. However, where one family member assumes substantial responsibility for another's long-term care, questions can arise about whether that care was intended to be provided voluntarily or whether payment should be expected.

The English High Court's decision in Rogers v Wills [2026] EWHC 2231 (Ch) highlights the potential financial consequences of informal family care arrangements and demonstrates that, in certain circumstances, they can give rise to legally enforceable payment obligations.

Background

The dispute arose following the death of Sheila Wills. Her daughter, Bernadette Rogers, had become her principal carer from September 2017 until her death in April 2020.

During this period, Sheila lived with Bernadette and her husband. Suffering from dementia and other medical conditions, Sheila required extensive assistance with everyday activities, personal care, medication, medical appointments and overnight supervision.

Following Sheila's death, Bernadette brought a claim against her brother, Andrew Wills, as executor of their mother's estate. She sought payment for the care provided, arguing that she and her mother had entered into an informal agreement under which she would receive reasonable remuneration.

The proceedings were determined in two stages. The first judgment, Rogers v Wills [2025] EWHC 1367 (Ch), addressed liability, while the subsequent 2026 judgment determined the amount payable.

Contractual liability: when informal arrangements become binding

In the first judgment, the court found that Sheila and Bernadette had entered into an agreement, in or around November 2017, under which Bernadette would provide care in return for reasonable payment.

In reaching that conclusion, the court considered the parties' intentions and the surrounding circumstances. It found that Sheila had the mental capacity to enter into the agreement and intended to create a legally binding arrangement with her daughter.

Although no specific fee had been agreed, the court concluded that a reasonable price could be implied. The absence of a written agreement or an expressly agreed payment figure did not prevent the arrangement from being enforceable.

This is an important reminder that family arrangements are not necessarily informal in the legal sense. The circumstances in which an arrangement is made, the discussions between the parties and their objectively ascertainable intentions may all be relevant when determining whether an entitlement to payment exists.

Assessing remuneration: the £127,500 award

Having established liability, the court was required to determine reasonable remuneration for the care provided.

Bernadette sought payment at £150 per day for 900 days, producing a claim of £135,000. The executor disputed this valuation, arguing that the care should be assessed by reference to a more limited number of hours and local authority care-worker rates.

The executor proposed a valuation based on limited daily care hours and local-government care-worker rates. The judge considered those rates as one useful cross-check, but found that two or three hours a day did not realistically reflect the care provided. The assessment instead took account of the substantial support, supervision and availability required, including overnight. The court also corrected the contractual period of care which was concluded to be 850 days, not 900.

The court also considered the likely commercial cost of obtaining comparable care from professional providers. It concluded that £150 per day over 850 days represented reasonable remuneration for the services provided and awarded £127,500, plus interest.

The court also distinguished the contractual claim from claims involving gratuitous care following personal injury. As Bernadette's entitlement arose under a contract, the court rejected the proposed deductions for income tax and National Insurance when calculating the award. However, the court did not determine the claimant’s actual tax liability.

The court also held, alternatively, that the estate would be liable in unjust enrichment because Sheila had accepted care knowing that payment was expected. The subsequent quantum trial proceeded solely on the contractual basis.

Wider case law

Although a lot has been made of the decision recently in both the legal and general press, it is not as novel a legal point as commentators may seek to make out. The decision sits within a wider body of case law concerning remuneration for services provided within families.

In Mate v Mate [2023] EWHC 238 (Ch), the court considered a claim involving substantial services provided by a daughter in connection with services toward her family-owned farmland business and land promotion. The court awarded £652,500 in unjust enrichment, demonstrating that services provided within a family may attract significant financial compensation where they were not intended to be gratuitous.

Other cases, including Housecroft v Burnett [1986] 1 All ER 332 and Evans v Pontypridd Roofing Ltd [2001] EWCA Civ 1657, consider the valuation of gratuitous care, including the use of commercial care rates as a benchmark.

However, Rogers v Wills does highlight the importance of distinguishing between a contractual entitlement to remuneration and a claim for compensation for gratuitous care. The legal basis of a claim can materially affect how the court assesses the amount payable.

Practical implications for families, executors and beneficiaries

In terms of practical considerations:

For families arranging care: Where one family member assumes substantial responsibility for another's care, expectations around payment should ideally be discussed at the outset. Any agreement should ideally be recorded in writing, addressing the nature of the care, the expected duration and how remuneration will be calculated.

For executors: Potential claims arising from care or other services provided during the deceased's lifetime should not be dismissed simply because the arrangement was between family members or was never formally documented. Executors should investigate the circumstances in an impartial fashion, including discussions about payment, correspondence and records of the services provided, before distributing estate assets. This will obviously be problematic when the person claiming payment is also an executor.

For beneficiaries: Claims for unpaid care can materially reduce the value of an estate available for distribution. Beneficiaries should therefore be aware that potential liabilities may need to be resolved before their inheritance can be finalised.

Conclusion

Although not a novel legal point, the timing and elderly care context in Rogers v Wills makes the decision particularly important for private wealth clients and practitioners. The growing costs of elder care and difficulties in funding it in the cost of living crisis - both for families and society at large - are well documented and have become something of a political ‘issue du jour’. We could well see this decision opening the floodgates to numerous claims made against Deceased estates on the same basis.

The £127,500 award illustrates that where an enforceable agreement for reasonable remuneration exists, the resulting liability for the estate can be substantial, even where no specific fee was agreed.

In terms of planning that can be undertaken to avoid disputes and unintended consequences, the key message is that family members and advisors should approach such matters with specificity, care, and clear communication.

If you are facing similar issues, or would like advice on avoiding disputes arising from family care arrangements, our Private Wealth Disputes lawyers would be happy to assist. Please do not hesitate to reach out.

Contributors

Richard Pike

Partner

Thomas Giles

Senior Solicitor