The health risks associated with asbestos exposure are often mistakenly regarded as an issue of the past. Due to its significant use in construction before all types were banned in 1999, exposure to legacy asbestos remains a risk today, with asbestos exposure responsible for approximately 3,500 cases of occupational cancer in the construction sector alone each year.

Against that background, and reflecting the HSE’s increased focus on health-related risks (which we have blogged about here), the HSE consulted in late 2025 on the effectiveness of the asbestos regulatory framework under the Control of Asbestos Regulations 2012 (CAR 2012).

The HSE has now published its response to that consultation. Here, we look at the outcome of the consultation, the changes that are afoot and what duty holders should be doing now.

CAR 2012

CAR 2012 provides the framework for managing asbestos in non-domestic premises. It requires those responsible for the maintenance, repair and management of buildings to identify asbestos-containing materials (ACMs), assess the risks they pose and ensure those risks are properly managed.

In addition, work with asbestos is highly regulated. It is categorised into ‘Licensable’, ‘Non-Licensable’ or ‘Notifiable Non-Licensed’ Work depending on the nature of the activities being carried out, with the specific regulatory requirements dependent on the categorisation. For example, employees carrying out Licensable or Notifiable Non-Licensed Work must be subject to health surveillance at least every two years and three years respectively.

Where work with asbestos has been carried out, the work area should be thoroughly cleaned before being handed over for reoccupation or for demolition. For Licensable Work (which applies to certain higher risk activities), a four-stage clearance process must be undertaken by an accredited analyst to provide independent assurance that the work has been completed safely. This involves preliminary checks, a visual inspection, clearance air monitoring and a final assessment, after which a Certificate of Reoccupation may be issued.

The consultation

The Consultation sought views on three key proposals aimed at better protecting workers and the public from exposure to legacy asbestos.

The first proposal

The first proposal was aimed at strengthening the independence and impartiality of those carrying out the four-stage clearance process following Licensable Works. Currently, the HSE’s Asbestos: Analyst’s Guide recommends that an independent analyst should carry out the final assessment; however, concerns have been raised that this approach does not sufficiently guard against potential conflicts of interest. Licensed asbestos removal contractors (“LARCs”) are able to appoint the analyst, leading to concerns that some LARCs are “marking their own homework”.

The HSE’s response to the first proposal is regulatory change. Regulation 20 of CAR 2012 (which sets out standards for air testing and site clearance certification) will be amended to require that the accredited specialist who carries out the four-stage clearance process is appointed by a party independent of the LARC, meaning this role will have to be fulfilled by the Client or another duty holder.

The amended Regulations will come into force on 24 November 2026, with a transition period of 12 months before HSE commences enforcement. The HSE has also confirmed it will update the Approved Code of Practice (L143): Managing and Working with Asbestos and Asbestos: The Analyst’s Guide to help duty holders appoint third party service providers with confidence.

The second proposal

The second proposal was aimed at improving the standard of asbestos surveys. Under CAR 2012, duty holders must maintain an asbestos management plan, which is reliant on the preparation of comprehensive and accurate asbestos surveys. The proposal acknowledged concerns around survey standards and aimed to improve guidance and strengthen duty holders’ understanding of the importance of robust surveying.

The HSE’s response has been to continue to “strongly recommend” the use of an accredited organisation when conducting an asbestos survey. However, accreditation will not be made mandatory. While the HSE recognises the benefits of accreditation, they highlight that survey quality ultimately depends on individual competence, experience and robust quality assurance. Cost concerns were also raised. The HSE will instead develop further guidance to help duty holders understand the critical role a quality survey plays in managing asbestos.

The third proposal

The third proposal was aimed at improving guidance to clarify what constitutes ‘Notifiable Non-Licensed Work’ (“NNLW”). Historically, confusion has arisen over the meaning of NNLW and this proposal was aimed at providing clarity and assisting understanding for duty holders.

The HSE’s response has confirmed that the NNLW category will be retained, but it will develop guidance to improve understanding of the meaning of this category and how it differentiates from Non-Licensable and Licensable Work.

What should duty holders do now?

The message is clear: asbestos management is a key regulatory focus for the HSE. In its Business Plan for 2026/2027, the HSE has undertaken to carry out 14,000 proactive inspections focussed on health risks, including asbestos exposure. Where they are inspected, duty holders will be expected to demonstrate to the HSE the systems they have in place for managing the risks associated with asbestos exposure (as well as other health risks). As such, duty holders should ensure that asbestos management forms a central part of their wider health and safety management system.

In addition, organisations involved in Licensable Work should review their processes for appointing contractors, ensuring compliance with the new independence obligations under the amended Regulation 20 of CAR 2012.

Finally, organisations should keep a close eye on further developments and ensure their existing asbestos management arrangements keep up with best practice.

If you would like to discuss your organisation’s requirements under CAR 2012, or any other aspect of Health and Safety, please get in touch with Brodies’ Health and Safety team or your usual Brodies contact.

Contributors

Amy Anderson

Senior Associate

Clare Bone

Partner & Solicitor Advocate

Lauren Chisholm

Solicitor

Sophia Alvi

Trainee Solicitor